Spiralvent

SPIRALVENT XIII

ANTINATALISM

My personal belief is that the human race would be benefited from voluntary extinction via the complete cessation of birth. The unavoidable, elementary truth is: if one does not exist, one does not suffer.

Most people I’ve spoken to about this subject recoil at antinatalism because they see it as the end of humanity. That thought is both ridiculous and frightening to them. I suspect it’s ridiculous before they ever make it to frightened. The reaction is defensive and they shut the conversation down before it’s even had. I need to meet more people.

What is wrong with antinatalism? What is wrong with not having children? You spare the unborn a life filled with disappointments, sadness, anger, despair, illness, heartbreak, pain, hunger, thirst, boredom, etc. Of course, the gut reaction is, “but there are pleasures in life too.” David Benatar’s axiological asymmetry comes to bear. The argument states that if you are not in existence, you do not experience pain. You also do not experience pleasure, but you are not in existence to be deprived of pleasure – you do not exist. Without going into the whole axiological argument, suffice to say, not existing is the better deal.

As for the objection to the end of humanity – from a simple viewpoint, new generations that aren’t born do not exist and therefore do not care one way or the other if humanity continues. They will not inherit our problems and issues that we leave them to solve alongside the inherent pains of living and supporting yourself.

I’m in no way saying that we throw humans under the bus. On the contrary, once you begin to exist, you deserve all the rights and privileges that are coming to you. You deserve to lead a good life with all the pleasures and goods you deserve. Just do not have children.

Antinatalism is not a far cry from what we’re currently observing culturally in North America. Young women (and men) are ambivalent on the topic of having children. Climate change, economic hardship, evolving gender roles, are all factoring in to people’s decisions regarding procreation. Admittedly, the “antinatalism” label can be seen as too harsh to describe the maternal ambivalence phenomenon. But “I’m not having children,” and “I’m not having children,” resemble each other.

I’m not an intellectual or even all that intelligent, but I try. This website is as much about antinatalism as it is about my trying to find intellectual footing. It’s where I practice my skill at making YouTube videos and where I practice my writing.

I subscribe to the Benatarian version of antinatalism and am learning more about it every day. If I come across an argument that takes it down, I will be the first one to let you know. I was first introduced to antinatalism on the Making Sense Podcast back in 2017. While Sam Harris is not an antinatalist, I continue to be heavily influenced by his thinking on major subjects. You’ll see a lot of his content on this site as well.

VIDEOISM

The @spiralvent YouTube channel is a philosophy and self-inquiry platform centered on antinatalism, existentialism, and philosophical pessimism. Associated with the companion website spiralvent.ca, the channel features candid, reflective discussions on the ethics of procreation, the nature of existence and non-existence, atheism, and moral philosophy—tackling subjects ranging from evolutionary flaws to how antinatalism intersects with broader social and political realities.

At the core of the channel’s philosophy is antinatalism—the ethical position that assigns a negative value to birth and argues that bringing new sentient beings into existence is morally problematic. Rather than stemming from misanthropy, the perspective presented on the channel is rooted in compassion and harm reduction: since all conscious life inevitably experiences suffering, vulnerability, and death without ever consenting to be born, abstaining from procreation is viewed as the most direct and humane way to prevent unnecessary pain.

Beyond structured philosophical critiques, the channel also serves as a space for unfiltered personal commentary and everyday observations. Alongside deeper dives into existential themes, episodes frequently blend casual walk-and-talk reflections with commentary on current events, social issues, and personal perspectives on navigating modern life.

False Premises

False Premises

In this post, I’ll be arguing against Richard Carrier’s second section of his essay, “Antinatalism Is Contrafactual & Incoherent.” The section is titled “Factually False Premises.”

What is initially striking about Carrier’s essay this far, is he keeps using the word/concept of “death” to situate antinatalism. To the contrary, antinatalism is about preventing the existence of sentient life, or not bringing new life into existence. Someone who never existed cannot experience death. It’s worth considering if Carrier is simply trying to prove that life is worth living by comparing the positive utility of life to the loss of death, but he makes numerous references to antinatalists wanting everyone to be dead.

The antinatalist needs it to be true that being dead is better than being alive. But it factually isn’t.

There is no sense in which “all humans always everywhere” are more miserable alive than dead.

If Douglass was better off freed than slave, he logically necessarily must have been better off alive than dead.

These quotes make it obvious that Carrier is either employing a sleight of hand in describing the antinatalism or he doesn’t realize the difference between not having been born and dying in the context of the philosophy. Using “death” as the alternative to “not having existed to begin with,” does add moral weight to his argument, however. Who wants to be “dead,” right? But by show of hands, who wants to be born? Hopefully this demonstrates a core principle of antinatalist thought.

Carrier goes on to cite the facts concerning the philosophy. He mentions that the World Happiness Report shows that inadequate social conditions cause unhappiness. This is, however, disingenuous at best. Who can deny that we all experience anger, despair, sadness, loss, disappointment, hunger, thirst, sickness and death? Of course, there are lives in certain jurisdictions that are happier, but even the best of lives contains considerable suffering, and that’s a fact. To quote David Benatar, if even a pin prick is the extent of suffering an existing person would experience, it would have been better had he not been born.

Carrier then describes a scenario in which the consent argument can be overridden by technological advancement.

see How Not to Live in Zardoz; where I even describe a condition—in no way obtaining now—in which having children would be immoral, but only because we could then create new people without making them children, which illustrates that as human civilization increases the available options, antinatalism looks even more ridiculous.

There are a few issues with this reasoning. This scenario does not escape Benatar’s asymmetry. Even as adults, people suffer asymmetrically. Carrier would admit that using technology cannot eliminate suffering. The point at which suffering is eliminated is indeterminate as of now. Added to that, consent is still violated when an adult is brought into existence fully formed. Autonomy in the conventional sense is absolutely felt and necessary for a fulfilling life, but free will is an illusion. We are slaves to biological and psychological predispositions as well as social and environmental circumstances.

The argument that “all these people” are mistaken about their own subjective feelings and are therefore “wrong” to say they like being alive is pseudoscientific bullshit. There only is how they feel. 

Understandably, assessing existing lives may offer insight into how a potential person may assess their own lives. However, this a flawed measure of life’s desirability. From the moment we’re born, we’re infused with an evolutionary drive to want to exist without even understanding that drive. As we grow older, we become self conscious and develop attachments, relationships, interests, etc. all while being oblivious to what any of it means. By the time we’re old enough to understand life, its challenges, pitfalls, pains, illness etc. we’re already locked in. In fact, it feels like a betrayal to say, “I wish I was never born.” Keep in mind saying you wish you were never born is not saying you wish you were dead. Antinatalists and Carrier agree that death is bad.

Carrier cannot dismiss well documented psychological phenomena that everyone uses to adapt to life’s disappointments or deteriorating conditions. Sure, people feel things, but it is disingenuous to say that feelings alone explain everything in life. Here is a list of some of these phenomena:

Pollyannaism (Optimism Bias)

Pollyannaism is the psychological tendency to emphasize positive experiences while downplaying negative ones. We tend to remember pleasant experiences more readily and anticipate a future that is better than it is likely to be. This can lead us to overestimate the quality of our lives.

Habituation

Habituation is the process by which repeated or prolonged exposure to an unpleasant condition reduces our psychological response to it. Over time, we become accustomed to discomfort, hardship or suffering. However, becoming accustomed to a negative condition does not necessarily diminish its objective badness.

Accommodation

Accommodation is the psychological tendency to adjust our expectations and standards in response to changing circumstances. When our quality of life deteriorates, we may lower our expectations to accommodate our new reality. Consequently, we may evaluate our lives positively despite an objective decline in our well-being.

Comparison

Comparison is the tendency to evaluate the quality of our lives relative to the lives of others. We may consider ourselves fortunate because others experience greater suffering. However, this can cause us to overlook the severity of harms that are widespread or universal to the human condition.

Source: David Benatar, Better Never to Have Been (2006), Chapter 3, pp. 64–69.

Humans are not just machines accessing “satisfaction-states.” We are complicated and sophisticated animals that don’t fully understand ourselves most times.

Carrier is also missing some major points of antinatalism. The philosophy does not cherry pick – it believes all lives are not worth starting, not just sub-groups that experience especially intense suffering.

We could cherry-pick past historical points, and present sub-groups, where we can find the exceptional block to accessible satisfaction states that antinatalism requires be the case for everyone. But those exceptions prove the rule: they are conditional. And when something is conditional, it goes away when you remove the condition. Sure, you can remove it with death.

The condition is life itself. You can’t ignore that life contains vast amounts of suffering that we adapt to but nevertheless experience. We get over suffering only so much, but scars, both psychological and physical, persist. Who could deny these truths?

Quite simply, you have two options: one with zero net utility (zero consciousness, zero pleasure, zero choice, zero degrees of freedom), and one with considerable net utility (consciousness, pleasure, choice, degrees of freedom). Imagine yourself in either state. Which, once in that state, would you prefer? The answer is obvious to all but the irrational.

In the state of “zero,” we must remind ourselves that there is no one there to experience “zero” or a lack of pleasure. It’s quite simply non-existence. In positive utility states, yes, there is pleasure, consciousness, choice, degrees of freedom, but those things are illusory to say the least. Accompanying those positive things are a lot of negative things – loss, disappointment, hunger, bereavement, illness, injury, death, etc.

Carrier then proceeds to explain his anti-antinatalist stance through a slave analogy. All through the analogy he keeps referring to slaves being better off dead as an antinatalist perspective. Again, conflating never having been brought into existence with death. What Carrier needs to be arguing against is promortalism. Antinatalism does not require suicide. If you’re satisfied with your life, then live it.

Back to Top