ANTINATALISM
Spiralvent XIII is a self education project based in Toronto, Canada. Its focus is on antinatalism.
My personal belief is that the human race would be benefited from voluntary extinction via the complete cessation of birth. The unavoidable, elementary truth is: if one does not exist, one does not suffer.
Most people I’ve spoken to about this subject recoil at antinatalism because they see it as the end of humanity. That thought is both ridiculous and frightening to them. I suspect it’s ridiculous before they ever make it to frightened. The reaction is defensive and they shut the conversation down before it’s even had. I need to meet more people.
What is wrong with antinatalism? What is wrong with not having children? You spare the unborn a life filled with disappointments, sadness, anger, despair, illness, heartbreak, pain, hunger, thirst, boredom, etc. Of course, the gut reaction is, “but there are pleasures in life too.” David Benatar’s axiological asymmetry comes to bear. The argument states that if you are not in existence, you do not experience pain. You also do not experience pleasure, but you are not in existence to be deprived of pleasure – you do not exist. Without going into the whole axiological argument, suffice to say, not existing is the better deal.
One may also object that humanity will come to an end. From a simple viewpoint, new generations that aren’t born do not exist and therefore do not care one way or the other if humanity continues. They will not inherit our problems and issues that we leave them to solve alongside the inherent pains of living and supporting yourself.
I’m in no way saying that we throw humans under the bus. On the contrary, once you begin to exist, you deserve all the rights and privileges that are coming to you. You deserve to lead a good life with all the pleasures and goods you deserve. Just do not have children.
Antinatalism is not a far cry from what we’re currently observing culturally in North America. Young women (and men) are ambivalent on the topic of having children. Climate change, economic hardship, evolving gender roles, are all factoring in to people’s decisions regarding procreation. Admittedly, the “antinatalism” label can be seen as too harsh to describe the maternal ambivalence phenomenon. But “I’m not having children,” and “I’m not having children,” resemble each other.
I’m not an intellectual or even all that intelligent, but I try. This website is as much about antinatalism as it is about my trying to find intellectual footing. It’s where I practice my skill at making YouTube videos and where I practice my writing.
I subscribe to the Benatarian version of antinatalism and am learning more about it every day. If I come across an argument that takes it down, I will be the first one to let you know. I was first introduced to antinatalism on the Making Sense Podcast back in 2017. While Sam Harris is not an antinatalist, I continue to be heavily influenced by his thinking on major subjects. You’ll see a lot of his content on this site as well.
VIDEOISM
The @spiralvent YouTube channel is a philosophy and self-inquiry platform centered on antinatalism, existentialism, and philosophical pessimism. Associated with the companion website spiralvent.ca, the channel features candid, reflective discussions on the ethics of procreation, the nature of existence and non-existence, atheism, and moral philosophy—tackling subjects ranging from evolutionary flaws to how antinatalism intersects with broader social and political realities.
At the core of the channel’s philosophy is antinatalism—the ethical position that assigns a negative value to birth and argues that bringing new sentient beings into existence is morally problematic. Rather than stemming from misanthropy, the perspective presented on the channel is rooted in compassion and harm reduction: since all conscious life inevitably experiences suffering, vulnerability, and death without ever consenting to be born, abstaining from procreation is viewed as the most direct and humane way to prevent unnecessary pain.
Beyond structured philosophical critiques, the channel also serves as a space for unfiltered personal commentary and everyday observations. Alongside deeper dives into existential themes, episodes frequently blend casual walk-and-talk reflections with commentary on current events, social issues, and personal perspectives on navigating modern life.
Incoherence
November 3, 2026 4:30 pm
this post was NOT generated by AI
This post is based on Richard Carrier’s essay, “Antinatalism Is Contrafactual & Incoherent.” Specifically the section titled “Incoherence.”
Antinatalism holds that being alive causes suffering, such that not being alive is better. This entails killing everyone, and yourself. To try and avoid this consequence, as antinatalists do, with an equivocation fallacy, like “suicide and murdering billions causes suffering; therefore we ought not commit suicide or exterminate people,” only proves the point. They are contradicting themselves. If becoming dead is suffering, then how can being dead be better than being alive? The only reason one can ever coherently be against mass suicide is to admit that staying alive is better than being dead. But that renounces the entire premise that antinatalism is built on. What we are left with is incoherent nonsense.
What Carrier is missing is a couple things. First, there is an alternative to killing everyone and suicide and that is never having been born to begin with. There is no contradiction when ANs say that murder is morally wrong. You are, by definition, violating the consent of those being murdered – murder causes suffering. Furthermore, Carrier is conflating “becoming dead” with not existing in the first place.
Secondly, this argument can be distilled by the AN concepts of “a life worth starting” and “a life worth continuing.” A life worth continuing is one that has already begun. A life that is self-conscious and has accrued interests; projects, relationships, meaning, etc. Forcibly taking those interests away via murder or coercive tactics is undeniably wrong. But that life also contains suffering, large amounts of it, that, no doubt, remains tolerable in the face of said interests.
On the other hand, no life is a life worth starting. Nonexistent life has not accrued the interests mentioned above. As a baseline, there is simply nothing there in terms of incentives to come into existence or be forcibly brought into existence. There aren’t even conscious interests. There is also zero suffering. Notwithstanding hypothetical ideas like Generic Subjective Continuity (GSC), suffering is completely absent before birth/conception.
If being dead actually was better than being alive, we should all seek death, and indeed give everyone death. It’s the only humane thing to do. Right? Antinatalism is really just a whitewashed Cthulhu cult. And there is no way to get around this consequence. Because it absolutely requires defending the premise “being alive causes enough suffering such that not being alive is better.” Yet this cannot be defended if you then import a new premise with a conflicting utility function, that “being alive does not cause enough suffering such that not being alive is better.” Hence saying “making people dead causes more suffering than letting them live” simply is a refutation of the antinatalist’s own premise. Because “being alive does not cause enough suffering such that not being alive is better” is literally the denial of “being alive causes enough suffering such that not being alive is better.” Death is the absence of all pain. So the only reason death can ever be bad is that it ends something good. Which requires admitting life is not only good, but so good as to warrant outlawing death. So the antinatalist has set themselves a doomed project. They want a certain outcome (to have their cake and eat it too: being against all having of kids and being against genocide and suicide), but there is simply no logically coherent way to get that outcome. Yes, they will haul out much hand waving and harrumphing in attempts to deny this and stick to their self-contradiction. But what we never get in those desperate flailings is facts or logic.
Again, Carrier makes reference to “being dead” which muddies the waters between “not having been born,” “not being alive,” and, “dying/death after being alive.” He then proceeds to compare two contradictory premises attributing them both to a confused AN:
- being alive causes enough suffering such that not being alive is better.
- being alive does not cause enough suffering such that not being alive is better.
Carrier is sneaking in two different meanings of “not being alive is better.” He makes repeated claims that ANs want to give everyone death. What AN claims is that once in existence, you should be free to continue your life as you see fit. However, your life will be filled with actual suffering alongside ongoing potential suffering. Had you never been born, you would never have experienced life and its contents, and you would not have experienced suffering since there is no one there/in existence to experience it.
With the two contradictory premises, it would be best to change the baseline of them to best suit the AN framework. Instead of “being alive,” it could look something like this:
- not being alive (not being born) causes no suffering such that not being alive is better.
- being alive (having been born) does not (usually) cause enough suffering such that not being alive is better
What Carrier doesn’t seem to understand is that the goods of life are persuasive enough to keep you in existence despite the bads. ANs also believe that there are scenarios where pain is so intolerable that suicide/euthanasia is the best course of action.
With reference to Carrier’s utility functions, they’re abstractions despite utilizing numbers. The value of good and bad in life cannot be calculated with mathematics.
Of course, one could bite the bullet, hail Cthulhu, and admit antinatalism does entail killing everyone and yourself, and start giving marching orders. That it has that outcome does not make it false. Maybe it’s true. Maybe we should hail Cthulhu and destroy the world. But that antinatalists recoil in horror at that conclusion calls into question the truth of their entire premise. In their very revulsion to this they reveal that even they don’t really believe that being dead is better than being alive. So you have to question what they are really on about. Their motives are clearly not rational. Which leaves something else.
In this summation of his thinking about AN’s rationality, he repeats a claim that AN is about killing everyone and yourself. This is patently false. Consent is a pivotal concept in AN and it strongly claims that no one’s consent should be violated. But AN is also internally coherent about murder and suicide. The philosophy is about pre-natal harm prevention, not post-natal death.








